This comes from Indivisible National and I wanted to share it with you in its totality.
Intersectionality & Allyship: The Pitfalls of Allyship
By Regan Byrd Consulting, LLC
By Regan Byrd Consulting, LLC
- Defensiveness
- Examples include: “I don’t understand what I did wrong”; “You misunderstood me”; “You don’t know my experiences”; “This is a distraction, we are losing sight of the real target” (especially common during election season)
- Unreceptive to criticism
- We must ask ourselves “what reason do I have to be defensive over this?” before reacting
(Recommended reading: The White Man’s Guilt by James Baldwin)
- Demanding To Be the Center
- White people often demand to be in the center of ally activism even though we are not the experts
- E.g. demanding our individuality to take precedence in a conversation (“Look at me as an individual, not as part of ‘white people’”)
- White people demanding that they get to decide when racism has occurred
- Speaking for/Dictating Work in the Community
- Dictating what the work of the community ‘should’ be
- Advising the community without being invited to give subject expertise (e.g. legal advice that you may have been asked to provide)
- Trying to propose actions without knowing the community's plans, what they have tried already, what their priorities are, e.g.: giving feedback and criticism when it is not asked for
- Virtue Signaling
- Trying to get the ‘good white-person’ label, often by interjecting virtues you claim to have, unprompted
- Embeds allyship in character rather than in action
- Validation Seeking
- Looking for reconfirmation of being ‘woke’ and a ‘good white-person’ when criticized by a POC for racist words or behavior; (either by asking a white person or a POC who you think will take your side)
- Expecting Kudos
- Doing things to get ‘credit’ from the community
- Performative allyship
- The Woke Olympics
- Favoring Visible Work Instead of the Invisible
- Only showing up for the fun stuff, rather than the less exciting parts, e.g. knocking on doors, phone banking, testifying
- Focusing on what you want to do, not where you are most needed, e.g. to provide the unglamorous but important resources such as space, transportation, and child care
- Avoidance
- Not intervening as an ally in a situation in which racism takes place in front of you
- Avoiding difficult conversations because you can afford to
- No System of Feedback from POC
- We need feedback to know if we are on the right track, e.g. accountability partners
- These partnerships must be consensual and compensated
- Not checking in with people affected by oppression
- Tokenization
- Using (physical) proximity to POC as virtue signaling or credentialing, e.g. “I have 2 black co-workers and 1 black friend, therefore I am work and not racist”
- Looking for a person of color to fill a leadership position in your Indivisible Group in order to check the mark of having a diverse leadership team
- Appropriation
- Defined as: involving a cultural artifact containing history and labor, which has been commodified and sold → whereby the profit goes to those who are selling the artifact, not those who worked to produce it and have ties to it → and whereby the original community has no control over the artifact (and how it is being presented and commodified) or the profit made off of the artifact
No comments:
Post a Comment